Which would you rather have?

Cliff Lee refuses to pitch on short rest. He has never done it before in his career and it goes against his routine regimen. The only way he would pitch 3 games is if he came in as a reliever in Game 7. The Giants will also not get dominated by Cliff Lee like everyone expects. He throws strikes and rarely goes outside of the strike zone. He is the kind of pitcher the Giants hit hard because they are free swingers and will go after the first pitch aggressively. The bigger question is if those hits are going to end up in a glove.